Through-composed songs

Putting music theory into practice
User avatar
sloop_john_b
Rick-a-holic
Posts: 13835
Joined: Tue Jan 25, 2005 6:00 am

Through-composed songs

Post by sloop_john_b »

I'm currently studying composition, both in private lessons and in a historical context. Right now, it's late-Renaissance and Baroque period.

In that era (15/16th century), songs were either strophic (i.e., used a reoccuring melody with different lyrics each time, what we'd call verses in pop music), or through-composed, having almost no repeating parts whatsoever.

I've been trying to think of pop/rock songs that are through-composed or at least close to it, and I can't seem to think of any. Excepting pseudo-avant-garde stuff like Revolution 9, of course. Can anybody think of something with no verses and no choruses, just new part after new part and so on?
User avatar
lyle_from_minneapolis
Advanced Member
Posts: 2530
Joined: Sun Nov 19, 2006 7:13 pm

Post by lyle_from_minneapolis »

Bohemian Rhapsody... let me think of some more.
Here is where I hide my music:
http://www.soundclick.com/MarkKaufman
User avatar
lyle_from_minneapolis
Advanced Member
Posts: 2530
Joined: Sun Nov 19, 2006 7:13 pm

Post by lyle_from_minneapolis »

Happiness Is A Warm Gun...
Here is where I hide my music:
http://www.soundclick.com/MarkKaufman
User avatar
lyle_from_minneapolis
Advanced Member
Posts: 2530
Joined: Sun Nov 19, 2006 7:13 pm

Post by lyle_from_minneapolis »

Abbey Road, side two...
Here is where I hide my music:
http://www.soundclick.com/MarkKaufman
User avatar
doctorwho
Veteran RRF member
Posts: 12522
Joined: Tue Jun 11, 2002 3:28 pm

Post by doctorwho »

One Man Band (Three Dog Night) comes close.
It is better, of course, to know useless things than to know nothing. - Seneca
User avatar
jps
RRF Consultant
Posts: 37132
Joined: Wed Feb 12, 2003 6:00 am

Post by jps »

Would something like Tales Of Topographic Oceans count? Especially side three.
User avatar
bitzerguy
RRF Consultant
Posts: 1678
Joined: Wed Feb 02, 2005 10:22 am

Post by bitzerguy »

Tubular Bells.

...Dean
...Dean
Never, ever drool on your surf shirt. It wrecks the solo.

660/12FG, 350V63/6FG, 620/6JG, 360WB/6DBG, Dingwall C1 #001, Prestige Heritage Elite FM
User avatar
longhouse
Advanced Member
Posts: 2103
Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2003 6:43 pm
Contact:

Post by longhouse »

'Song Of Solomon' by Steve Kilbey may fit the bill.

I'm guessing this style of composition is extremely rare in rock / pop music. Even the prog crowd likes to give the songs an anchor.
Shaking the floor of Heaven
User avatar
longhouse
Advanced Member
Posts: 2103
Joined: Fri Apr 11, 2003 6:43 pm
Contact:

Post by longhouse »

Wait! I think I have a through-composition for you: http://www.myspace.com/noelchristianriddell

Click on 'We Could Glow'. It begins and ends in a similar way but nothing else repeats. And dig those Rickenbacker tones. Image

Cheers.
Shaking the floor of Heaven
User avatar
sloop_john_b
Rick-a-holic
Posts: 13835
Joined: Tue Jan 25, 2005 6:00 am

Post by sloop_john_b »

Noel, i'll definitley check out your song later!

Bohemian Rhapsody is very close, good thinking! Ditto for Happiness is a Warm Gun.

Abbey Road side 2, hmm, not sure about that one. "Sun King" has verses, "Mean Mr. Mustard" and "Polythene Pam" have two verses each. "She Came In Through..." definitley has a few repeating motifs. Were you thinking of the second side all as one song basically?
User avatar
jimk
RRF Consultant
Posts: 5353
Joined: Thu Jan 25, 2007 7:27 am
Contact:

Post by jimk »

How about McCartney's "Band on the Run?"

JimK
User avatar
lyle_from_minneapolis
Advanced Member
Posts: 2530
Joined: Sun Nov 19, 2006 7:13 pm

Post by lyle_from_minneapolis »

What John is looking for wouldn't have any repeated phrases, and "Band On The Run" has a chorus that repeats.

I was sort of kidding with Abbey Road side two, but a song like "You Never Give Me Your Money" does seem to continue from one musical idea to another.

Even Tales from Topographic Oceans, though it drifts about, keeps coming back to a repeated phrase.

John, this is hard. I can't think of any more, and it illustrates both the difficulty of writing a good through-composed piece as well as our preference for hooks, something we can remember over and over again. I think it even explains why people collect DVDs. :-D But really, the era for this sort of thing in pop music was late 60's early 70's. But even then, these long pieces tended to have at least one thing repeated. "Picasso's Last Words..." close but not it. I would think there is probably something by Genesis or Renaissance or Camel or Gentle Giant, but I can't remember much of their music. Yes may have something, but classical thinking always leads them back to a repetition. Dylan broke a lot of boundaries, but not this one. Neil Young's "Expecting to Fly" nearly does it. Joni Mitchell could write the world's longest verses, but they would repeat. What's a good example from outside the pop world?

This kind of challenge keeps me awake at night. If I'm still up at 3am thinking about John Biscuti, I think you'll owe me a beer.
Here is where I hide my music:
http://www.soundclick.com/MarkKaufman
User avatar
sloop_john_b
Rick-a-holic
Posts: 13835
Joined: Tue Jan 25, 2005 6:00 am

Post by sloop_john_b »

"You Never Give Me Your Money" is another great one. Dylan? The complete opposite! He's the epitome of "strophic".

I don't know if this will work for everyone, but here's something through composed - a 14th century motet, Dum complerentur, by Palestrina. If it doesn't work, i'll upload it elsewhere. It's an incredible piece of music, one of my favorites. I can also scan the score (six voices) if anyone is interested.

http://www.yousendit.com/download/T1VrT ... M2w1VEE9PQ

Mark, i've got an idea. Come to MARF, i'll buy you a beer, and we'll listen to some through-composed Baroque-era madrigals. Image
User avatar
jimk
RRF Consultant
Posts: 5353
Joined: Thu Jan 25, 2007 7:27 am
Contact:

Post by jimk »

What John is looking for wouldn't have any repeated phrases, and "Band On The Run" has a chorus that repeats.


OK, I couldn't remember for sure. I don't have the album.

Yeah, this is difficult. I have my doubts that such a thing exists in 20th century popular music.

JimK
User avatar
jdogric12
Rick-a-holic
Posts: 10853
Joined: Thu Dec 29, 2005 6:00 am

Post by jdogric12 »

First of all, this thread kicks all kinds of butt. Way to go, John!

"Cigarette" by Ben Folds Five comes close, it's kind of AA'. (That's "A" followed by "A prime," which is like "A" but a hair different.)

"The Waiting Room (aka The Evil Jam)" by Genesis is kind of close, but it falls more into the Revolution 9 category.
Post Reply

Return to “Being For The Benefit Of Musicianship”