Folkie wrote:David,
I've been listening to R.E.M. since "Lifes Rich Pageant" came out in 1986, so I find the depth and breadth of your gear knowledge (amassed over the last 20 years or so) more than mildly astonishing. By the way, you're absolutely right about the shift in Bill Berry's drum style circa LRP. It's always a pleasure to listen to the spirited discussion between you and Werner on these matters. Keep the insights coming!
Robert
Here's another funny Bill Berry drum fact then, related to another song from that Raleigh show.
I've always found the timbale-sounding intro and fills in Laughing really cool, and was always puzzled that Bill who otherwise had a rather "conservative" drumset setup (very standard 5-piece kit, just the china being a little unusual) would get a timbale and add it to his set. You can see an extra drum to the right (his left) side of the snare. Also Laughing is pretty much one of the very few songs (if not the oly one) where it was used live. I asked Bill about this back in November of last year when I met him on one of my pilgrimages to Athens, GA and he explained that it actually wasn't a proper timbale but just an extra tom that he tuned really high. In is words: "hell, I had no chance of affording a proper timbale back then..."
Here's that timbale put to use in the intro to Laughing. Clear Bill Berry backing vocals in the chorus, too...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iPE-l-tfN0I#t=5m24s