Page 2 of 2
Re: Another Gibson winner!
Posted: Sat Nov 13, 2010 12:15 am
by whojamfan
kiramdear wrote:Well, take away the teeny-bopper hype and give it a decent finish and I'd play it. Features aren't bad.
Sorry M'Dear, that's a custom shop model starting at 2250
Yeah, under 500 bucks, 2 p90s and a solid finish, I'd check that out. I already have the satin white 2 pickup MM I paid 3 something for when they first started making them again a few years ago, not a bad guitar at all really.
Re: Another Gibson winner!
Posted: Sat Nov 13, 2010 3:06 am
by kiramdear
A Melody Maker with P-90s sounds all right to me. Back in the day, everybody modded those guitars.
Re: Another Gibson winner!
Posted: Sat Nov 13, 2010 10:20 am
by Clint
I don't have any problem with the Jonas Brothers. They play solid, modern pop as good as anybody out there. They've also been playing Gibson guitars for years. Still, I fail to see the logic here. I don't agree with their marketing blurb that this guitar will have "broad appeal". Like someone already said, this should be an Epiphone model with a modest price.
I have to say, watching Gibson's corporate meltdown has been quite entertaining these past few years. Although I do feel sorry for all those employees that really do care about their products and the company's reputation.
Re: Another Gibson winner!
Posted: Sat Nov 13, 2010 11:19 am
by jingle_jangle
beatbyrd wrote:bartyclue wrote:The Hanson brothers are furious!!!
Very, very funny, Sir!
But..... just to play devil's advocate here. If these guys turn out to have some staying power (doubtful), these guitars could become collector's items down the road. You have to figure that at least half the run of 300 will go to l'il Johnnie or Suzie and get trashed very quickly.
Musically, I remember similar comments made about the Monkees in their day. Heck, my buddies and I constantly mocked both the Monkees and their fans back then. Only a total loser would buy and play a Monkees Gretsch! Flash forward a few decades and people have great memories about the Monkees, their fantastic music, and the Gretsch is sought after. But, having said all that, there's no way I'd consider buying one of these to play. I think the Taylor Swift model Taylor is a better long term investment, anyway. Tom
One big difference, and that difference is 40+ years!
We've had thousands of hype-created groups since the Monkees. We're tired of them. We appreciate real talent. Not saying that the Jonas Briothers don't have any, but to me they seem to be more Menudo than Monkee.
This guitar has a MSRP of over a grand. How many tweener fans do you suppose are going to find this under their Christmas tree?
(Well, Henry's only looking to sell 300...it gets weirder still...are his bankers THAT square?)
And I prefer the Taylor Swift model Swift.
Re: Another Gibson winner!
Posted: Sat Nov 13, 2010 11:34 am
by Clint
beatbyrd wrote:..... just to play devil's advocate here. If these guys turn out to have some staying power (doubtful), these guitars could become collector's items down the road.
That's true enough, but That's only going to help vintage guitar dealers and collectors. I don't see how that helps Gibson.
Re: Another Gibson winner!
Posted: Sat Nov 13, 2010 3:36 pm
by RIC_FACTORY
Someone made the comment comparing them to The Beatles and said the fact that they have a backup band is not a big deal since a lot of artists/groups have them these days.
So that got me to thinking... Who exactly played in the backup band for The Beatles? I mean, who was there just in case John or George missed a note? Pretty clever how The Beatles were able to hide the supporting musicians at all their live shows.
Re: Another Gibson winner!
Posted: Sat Nov 13, 2010 4:02 pm
by admin
Great question. Jimmy Nichol sat in on drums for roughly three-quarters of the performances when Ringo was ill for the first Beatles' World Tour in June 1964.
Re: Another Gibson winner!
Posted: Sat Nov 13, 2010 4:43 pm
by paologregorio
paologregorio wrote:Jeez, could they have missed their mark by more than they have with this? This model should have been an unlimted run of Epiphones at a price point aimed at beginning guitar players who like the Jonas Brothers. They would have sold a pile of them. Duh.
I can't speak for anyone else, but I have no beef with the Jonas Brothers.
I can't name any of their songs, but it would be cool to be in a situation like the Jonas Brothers; make a pile of cash performing one's own pop numbers to tons of adoring fans, with your own siblings, provided it wasn't like a Davies or Gallagher brothers-type relationship. My comment was that Gibson completely missed the mark with the Jonas Brothers Sig model these -see above.
Re: Another Gibson winner!
Posted: Sat Nov 13, 2010 5:08 pm
by Clint
I hear ya. It just begs the question, how can Gibson misread its own customer base so often and so completely?
Re: Another Gibson winner!
Posted: Sat Nov 13, 2010 6:10 pm
by weemac
kiramdear wrote:Well, take away the teeny-bopper hype and give it a decent finish and I'd play it. Features aren't bad.
I was going to post something to this effect Kira...
I have something nearly as bad.......
Eden.
Re: Another Gibson winner!
Posted: Sun Nov 14, 2010 7:14 pm
by cassius987
I like that shell pink SG, Eden. Nothing to be ashamed of.
Re: Another Gibson winner!
Posted: Mon Nov 15, 2010 2:14 pm
by JakeK
winston wrote:The guitar is sure to be a hit with.....................still thinking about that one.........................still thinking....................hmmm......................little girls with rich daddies?
Best comment of the year!
Also I like...
paologregorio wrote:Jeez, could they have missed their mark by more than they have with this? This model should have been an unlimted run of Epiphones at a price point aimed at beginning guitar players who like the Jonas Brothers. They would have sold a pile of them. Duh.
I know you have no beef against the Jo Bros (Disney girls call them this), Paul, heck I'd love to be in their situation, too, but you have to know the right people, and they obviously did.
Re: Another Gibson winner!
Posted: Mon Nov 15, 2010 3:21 pm
by octagon
Re: Another Gibson winner!
Posted: Mon Nov 15, 2010 3:38 pm
by Grey
It has a full-sized headstock, double pickups with matching pickguard, and selector switch. So i'm not really sure what part of this guitar is a Melody Maker other than the pickguard vaguely resembling it but not even bearing the Melody Maker name. Also, could they have put the pickup selector in a
worse position on that guitar? Yea, i'm sure sticking it directly underneath the 'sweet spot' picking area was brilliant.
Re: Another Gibson winner!
Posted: Thu Dec 30, 2010 3:25 pm
by 77jordan
antipodean wrote:I prefer the Squier "Hello Kitty" stratocaster - way more cred for way less cash....
This
