Page 4 of 13
Re: 8 String Bass Bridges with 8 Saddles
Posted: Thu Dec 09, 2010 1:21 pm
by Low End Lover
johnhall wrote:If these are aluminum, chances are they're going to bind big time after a fairly short period of time.
Since these are, can someone explain what this means and the issue it will cause?
Thanks,
LEL (Jason)
Re: 8 String Bass Bridges with 8 Saddles
Posted: Thu Dec 09, 2010 1:32 pm
by aceonbass
My 5-string aluminum bridges that I use for my 4-2-5 conversions are machined out of aluminum also. I haven't had or heard of any problems yet, but mine weren't chrome plated either. Maybe this makes the tolerances to tight or something?
Re: 8 String Bass Bridges with 8 Saddles
Posted: Thu Dec 09, 2010 1:50 pm
by teeder
Thanks to Dane and John for the input.
The bridges will be flash chromed, so the build up will be at a minimum.
John, please elaborate as to what binding issues we may run into.
Thanks!
Re: 8 String Bass Bridges with 8 Saddles
Posted: Sat Dec 11, 2010 12:22 am
by Low End Lover
Paging Mr. Hall... Help us out please!
Re: 8 String Bass Bridges with 8 Saddles
Posted: Sat Dec 11, 2010 10:56 am
by Ric N. Backer
You might want to consider soliciting John Hall's input, regrading the technical stuff, off-line.
Re: 8 String Bass Bridges with 8 Saddles
Posted: Sat Dec 11, 2010 11:45 am
by aceonbass
Low End Lover wrote:Paging Mr. Hall... Help us out please!
He already helped us out by saying these were okay to make and advising that brass was a better material. Not that I doubt anything he would say, but once you've intonated your 8-string with these aluminum bridges, I don't think you'll be doing it again any time soon, so the binding issue shouldn't surface in normal use. Like I said earlier, my CNC'd aluminum 5-string RIC-style bass bridges are just fine.
Re: 8 String Bass Bridges with 8 Saddles
Posted: Sat Dec 11, 2010 12:08 pm
by cjj
When two metals, especially soft ones like aluminum, and often when they are the same metal, are in contact under pressure, you can get "galling". This is a plastic deformation and adhesion between the surfaces. This can happen with just pressure, but is worse with movement/friction.
The chrome plating will help, but if it's thin, may not be enough...
Re: 8 String Bass Bridges with 8 Saddles
Posted: Sat Dec 11, 2010 12:54 pm
by rickaddict
cjj wrote:When two metals, especially soft ones like aluminum, and often when they are the same metal, are in contact under pressure, you can get "galling". This is a plastic deformation and adhesion between the surfaces. This can happen with just pressure, but is worse with movement/friction.
The chrome plating will help, but if it's thin, may not be enough...
I've heard of something similar happening with high-end lightweight bicycle parts...
Would it help if a thin layer of grease were applied to the mating surfaces?

Re: 8 String Bass Bridges with 8 Saddles
Posted: Sun Dec 12, 2010 7:46 pm
by cassius987
teeder wrote:Josh,
Sorry man, the number of bridges is 8. One was a prototype that has some machining issue.
That's okay. I have too many other irons in the fire anyways.
Re: 8 String Bass Bridges with 8 Saddles
Posted: Sun Dec 12, 2010 9:53 pm
by weemac
rickaddict wrote:cjj wrote:When two metals, especially soft ones like aluminum, and often when they are the same metal, are in contact under pressure, you can get "galling". This is a plastic deformation and adhesion between the surfaces. This can happen with just pressure, but is worse with movement/friction.
The chrome plating will help, but if it's thin, may not be enough...
I've heard of something similar happening with high-end lightweight bicycle parts...
Would it help if a thin layer of grease were applied to the mating surfaces?

I remember once making a model steam engine and I used brass for the cylinder and aluminium for the piston. When I test fitted it slid in and bound. It was like it was welded in there. I mangled both parts trying to seperate them.
I think I used brass and bronze for my next effort and that worked fine (until the boiler blew up)
Eden.
Re: 8 String Bass Bridges with 8 Saddles
Posted: Sun Dec 12, 2010 10:03 pm
by aceonbass
Aluminum and brass have two different rates of expansion. Kevin's bridge and saddles are made of the same material. I would think that unless you're cycling the saddles back and for a couple hours at a time, there would be no issues. As I've said, I use zinc RIC bass saddles on aluminum 5-string bridges with NO problem at all.
Re: 8 String Bass Bridges with 8 Saddles
Posted: Sun Dec 12, 2010 11:03 pm
by weemac
Well the original cast aluminium bridge had saddles to match and the chrome did a good job of stopping the saddles binding in most cases.
Kevin are the bridges left as a solid bar or are they hollowed like the Rickenbacker ones?
On my 4008 the bridge has sagged a bit in the middle and is held from deforming further by the grub screws locking into the holes in the tailpiece (previous owner had fairly heavy strings on it). A slightly more solid 8 string bridge is not a bad idea.
Eden.
Re: 8 String Bass Bridges with 8 Saddles
Posted: Mon Dec 13, 2010 9:13 am
by teeder
Hollowed, but the side walls are thicker.
Re: 8 String Bass Bridges with 8 Saddles
Posted: Mon Dec 13, 2010 2:54 pm
by henry5
Kevin, if you ever do anymore I may be interested.
Re: 8 String Bass Bridges with 8 Saddles
Posted: Mon Dec 13, 2010 4:14 pm
by weemac
teeder wrote:Hollowed, but the side walls are thicker.
Good stuff! It will put the strength up and keep the tone nice and even.....
Eden.