Tweaking "The Bells Of Rhymney"
Posted: Sat Sep 29, 2007 1:43 pm
This is one that I tread on, and "Mess with" carefully and gingerly; for I believe (The only exception being that Gene didn't write it) that this song absolutely personifies everything that is so special about this band.
Without question, the "Magnum Opus" from "The Original 5".
For this reason, I've done very little in any kind of re-arranging, etc to this track. It stands alone as something really spectacular.
Many years ago, I started playing with that little turnaround right before the guitar solo:
-------------------------------------------------------------
"Why so worried, sisters why, say the silver bells and wye".
-------------------------------------------------------------
This is what I came up with. Try these chords during that passage:
X00232 XX0432 320002 & 020102
The first chord of course, is your standard D.
The second chord is Bm/D. When the guitars change to a Bm here, Chris continues to "Ride" the D, and if you have your "Crosby" play a full barre Bm, with Roger's part accentuating what Chris is doing, it REALLY adds to the "Bluegrass/Raga" element. The trick is keeping the D string OPEN while going to the second chord.
Here is where the twist comes in:
The third chord, I change from a standard G, into a Gmaj7 (Note: It should be a "Broken" voicing like shown, and not a "B minorish" Gmaj7 like the Bm/D I use for the second chord)
Much like the second chord in "Lyin' Eyes" by The Eagles, in other words.
The forth chord is an E7add F# (I'm sure there is another name for it)
Have your Crosby play a stock E major, however. You don't want the 7th to be "Too dominant"
So what's going on here now?
What's happening, is that you now have a high F# on ALL FOUR CHORDS (2nd fret, high E string).
It makes this passage all the more beautiful and poignant; so much so, you'll want to cry. (At least for me it does! :0)
The rest of the song, it's note for note for me; I don't change a thing.
I've had thoughts of arranging it with actual bells starting the tune off, and maybe a Sitar or Tamboura tuned to d droning along, but this might be "Gilding the lily", so to speak.
Immediately following is the guitar solo; THE GUITAR SOLO.
In fact, it's my favourite guitar solo on the face of the Earth.
People are always more impressed if I pull out the intro to "The Spirit Of Radio" by RUSH, but it's ALWAYS TBOR for me.
During that last chord of the solo; the diminished one (What's the name-help me guys!!) The picking goes into full "Scruggs overdrive", and it's MOVIN'.
In fact you can hear; almost feel Roger wrestling with that Rickenbacker. He pulls it off (No pun!), but he's workin' there, to be sure.
Another important point here:
JUST LIKE "TURN!", DAVID CROSBY USES A "DROP D" TUNING. YOU CAN REALLY HERE IT ON THE LEFT CHANNEL, AND SEE IT AT "THE BIG TNT SHOW".
So of course, your fingering on the low E for David's parts are moved up two frets; one step.
This is yet another reason to make Roger's parts interesting, as David has his hands full just playing "Stock" chords, if you will.
In fact, David's part during that 4 chord turnaround arrangement I'm suggesting, should simply be this: D Bm G E
So, with the "Drop D", Crosby should look like this during that turnaround:
000232 024422 555403 222100
Nothing more, nothing less.
ALSO, THE 12 STRING IS UNQUESTIONABLY DOUBLE TRACKED ON THIS SONG; YOU CAN REALLY HEAR IT WHEN ROGER GOES TO THE A CHORDS, LIKE ON "CARDIFF", "MERTHYR", "RHONDA", ETC.
My old keyboardest, John Marino (Who is a gifted prodigy BTW-96 Tears to Stravinsky, and EVERYTHING in between) made an EXCELLENT point once:
"Think about it Chris, when the Ricky 12 was designed and made, it wasn't NECCESSARILY intended to be played like a Banjo".
We've already talked about the "Anomaly" like qualities of the instrument; it's oddities, it's difficulties, etc.
So what remains is this:
PLAYING THE RICKENBACKER 12 STRING GUITAR LIKE ROGER MCGUINN IS A HELL OF ALOT TOUGHER AND HARDER THAN IT LOOKS AND SOUNDS. :0)
Enjoy, and God Bless,
Christian
"The Boxart Den"-World's largest display & collection of FULLY RESTORED rare & collectable model kit box art
http://theboxartden.com
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Box-Art
http://www.myspace.com/craviola990
http://www.youtube.com/craviola990
Without question, the "Magnum Opus" from "The Original 5".
For this reason, I've done very little in any kind of re-arranging, etc to this track. It stands alone as something really spectacular.
Many years ago, I started playing with that little turnaround right before the guitar solo:
-------------------------------------------------------------
"Why so worried, sisters why, say the silver bells and wye".
-------------------------------------------------------------
This is what I came up with. Try these chords during that passage:
X00232 XX0432 320002 & 020102
The first chord of course, is your standard D.
The second chord is Bm/D. When the guitars change to a Bm here, Chris continues to "Ride" the D, and if you have your "Crosby" play a full barre Bm, with Roger's part accentuating what Chris is doing, it REALLY adds to the "Bluegrass/Raga" element. The trick is keeping the D string OPEN while going to the second chord.
Here is where the twist comes in:
The third chord, I change from a standard G, into a Gmaj7 (Note: It should be a "Broken" voicing like shown, and not a "B minorish" Gmaj7 like the Bm/D I use for the second chord)
Much like the second chord in "Lyin' Eyes" by The Eagles, in other words.
The forth chord is an E7add F# (I'm sure there is another name for it)
Have your Crosby play a stock E major, however. You don't want the 7th to be "Too dominant"
So what's going on here now?
What's happening, is that you now have a high F# on ALL FOUR CHORDS (2nd fret, high E string).
It makes this passage all the more beautiful and poignant; so much so, you'll want to cry. (At least for me it does! :0)
The rest of the song, it's note for note for me; I don't change a thing.
I've had thoughts of arranging it with actual bells starting the tune off, and maybe a Sitar or Tamboura tuned to d droning along, but this might be "Gilding the lily", so to speak.
Immediately following is the guitar solo; THE GUITAR SOLO.
In fact, it's my favourite guitar solo on the face of the Earth.
People are always more impressed if I pull out the intro to "The Spirit Of Radio" by RUSH, but it's ALWAYS TBOR for me.
During that last chord of the solo; the diminished one (What's the name-help me guys!!) The picking goes into full "Scruggs overdrive", and it's MOVIN'.
In fact you can hear; almost feel Roger wrestling with that Rickenbacker. He pulls it off (No pun!), but he's workin' there, to be sure.
Another important point here:
JUST LIKE "TURN!", DAVID CROSBY USES A "DROP D" TUNING. YOU CAN REALLY HERE IT ON THE LEFT CHANNEL, AND SEE IT AT "THE BIG TNT SHOW".
So of course, your fingering on the low E for David's parts are moved up two frets; one step.
This is yet another reason to make Roger's parts interesting, as David has his hands full just playing "Stock" chords, if you will.
In fact, David's part during that 4 chord turnaround arrangement I'm suggesting, should simply be this: D Bm G E
So, with the "Drop D", Crosby should look like this during that turnaround:
000232 024422 555403 222100
Nothing more, nothing less.
ALSO, THE 12 STRING IS UNQUESTIONABLY DOUBLE TRACKED ON THIS SONG; YOU CAN REALLY HEAR IT WHEN ROGER GOES TO THE A CHORDS, LIKE ON "CARDIFF", "MERTHYR", "RHONDA", ETC.
My old keyboardest, John Marino (Who is a gifted prodigy BTW-96 Tears to Stravinsky, and EVERYTHING in between) made an EXCELLENT point once:
"Think about it Chris, when the Ricky 12 was designed and made, it wasn't NECCESSARILY intended to be played like a Banjo".
We've already talked about the "Anomaly" like qualities of the instrument; it's oddities, it's difficulties, etc.
So what remains is this:
PLAYING THE RICKENBACKER 12 STRING GUITAR LIKE ROGER MCGUINN IS A HELL OF ALOT TOUGHER AND HARDER THAN IT LOOKS AND SOUNDS. :0)
Enjoy, and God Bless,
Christian
"The Boxart Den"-World's largest display & collection of FULLY RESTORED rare & collectable model kit box art
http://theboxartden.com
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Box-Art
http://www.myspace.com/craviola990
http://www.youtube.com/craviola990