Page 1 of 3
12 string problem
Posted: Sun May 04, 2008 5:45 am
by Rickygirl
I put this on someone elses thread, so thought I would throw it open to the House....
I have had trouble with the nut on my 12 string. The strings don't sit right down into the grooves and when I tune it, the string stretches without moving and then suddenly gives and it goes sharp. My friend and guitar guru Mickey, had to fiddle about with it and put a mix of different strings on to get it right. The Rickenbacker strings just don't fit into the nut. He thought about filing down the grooves slightly to help, but is a bit anxious doing this. I ordered a new nut just in case it all went horribly wrong and Paul A suggested lighter strings. I do find it fairly difficult to play and tend to "clunk" the bottom E and A harmony strings. Mickey has been promising to do all this this for me, but he is trying to avoid it I think. He is very good with his "luthiering", but has been learning about Ricks on mine.
Any thought chaps?
Re: 12 string problem
Posted: Sun May 04, 2008 11:02 am
by paologregorio
I've read about this problem before on this forum but haven't encountered it myself. First you'll want to make sure that Mickey has put the strings in the correct slots, as Rick 12s are strung the opposite from other 12 strings. From the top of the guitar down, the main string is first, then the harmony string is below it. Did the strings on the guitar when you bought it fit in the slots?
Re: 12 string problem
Posted: Sun May 04, 2008 1:10 pm
by Rickygirl
I know which way round the strings are supposed to be Paul. Give me some credit.
The shop restrung it for me when I bought it and they didn't fit the slots then. They put Rick strings on. This is why Mickey fiddled about with it and restrung it again with different strings.
Re: 12 string problem
Posted: Sun May 04, 2008 2:30 pm
by scotty
Hi Sarah.The mad Scotsman here how you doing?I was just wondering what gauge of strings are you using right now and is this on your lovely 360 BB that this is happening?
Re: 12 string problem
Posted: Sun May 04, 2008 2:33 pm
by doctorwho
Sarah, I suggest that you also post this under The Vibrola section, as it sounds like you need our expert luthiers' opinions.
IMO the nut slots are not cut wide enough; the strings should fit all the way in the slot, and the slots should be cut with a slight angle down toward the headstock (the highest point being near the fretboard).
Re: 12 string problem
Posted: Sun May 04, 2008 2:46 pm
by tennis_nick
sounds like the slots need to be widened just a touch.
If you don't want to go through the trouble, a friend of mine once went from 9's to 11's, and to make the slots wider, he took the string and ran it through the slot like a saw! hehehe, probably not the most high tech method, but that Les Paul NEVER goes out of tune!
Re: 12 string problem
Posted: Sun May 04, 2008 3:07 pm
by jingle_jangle
See my response in your other thread post...
A good reason not to cross-post, BTW.
Re: 12 string problem
Posted: Sun May 04, 2008 7:10 pm
by jps
jingle_jangle wrote:A good reason not to cross-post, BTW.
With eyes like those it is hard not to cross....
Re: 12 string problem
Posted: Sun May 04, 2008 11:24 pm
by brianeharmonjr
I don't see why someone would be so sheepish about filing out the slots in the nut. It's a pretty standard repair. I also add a little liquid graphite in the slots when I do this.
Re: 12 string problem
Posted: Sun May 04, 2008 11:29 pm
by deaconblues
I had a guitar nut pretty much ruined by a stupid tech at a reputable store...not that far-fetched.
Re: 12 string problem
Posted: Mon May 05, 2008 1:29 am
by jingle_jangle
brianeharmonjr wrote:I don't see why someone would be so sheepish about filing out the slots in the nut. It's a pretty standard repair. I also add a little liquid graphite in the slots when I do this.
Rickenparalysis, plain and simple. A temporary condition brought on by fear of messing things up when confronted by a legendary brand of guitar that many know nothing about. As if it ran on unobtanium or sumthin'.
Re: 12 string problem
Posted: Mon May 05, 2008 11:30 am
by jimk
jingle_jangle wrote:... As if it ran on unobtanium or sumthin'.
Paul, you crack me up!
JimK
Re: 12 string problem
Posted: Mon May 05, 2008 3:02 pm
by Rickygirl
scotty wrote: was just wondering what gauge of strings are you using right now and is this on your lovely 360 BB that this is happening?
Hi Scott. Yes, it is my 360 Blue Boy. I think the strings are 9's, but I do have some 8's to try.
Thank you for the responses chaps. Doing something that is irrepairable if you "**** it up" is the reason for being a bit of a Shaun.
I know I cross posted. Sorry.
Should I still post this on the Vibrola section still?
Re: 12 string problem
Posted: Mon May 05, 2008 3:17 pm
by Rickygirl
Paul W, In reply to your reply on the other thread, I understand what you are saying about the guage of strings. One reason I wanted to try the lighter ones was because I sometimes have difficulty putting enough pressure on the harmony string on the bottom E and A to stop it clunking. I realise this is lousy playing, and I had even considered selling it as I couldn't play it to it's full potential. Maybe having the slots in the nut widened will help a bit, but i don't think I can manage the Rick strings even though I have a set in my guitar box together with the 8s.
Maybe I should consider selling it to someone who can play it properly.

Re: 12 string problem
Posted: Mon May 05, 2008 3:34 pm
by tennis_nick
I think you can solve the problem without selling your beloved guitar.
One thing that I did to make playing easier was to tune down to Eb. Basically, you're in standard tuning but all the strings are down 1/2 step. It's easier for me to sing, and easier for the fingers to fret and bend. Plus, you retain the tone of the slightly larger strings. I find 10's in Eb are as slinky as you'll ever want to get. That 1/2 step down makes for a big lush tone I find, but that's just me...