Tonal differences - 2 or 3 pups on 300-series Rics
Posted: Mon Feb 02, 2009 12:52 pm
Hello, all, new to the forum.
Three years back I purchased a 360/12 and put a 12-string saddle (duh) and scatterwounds on it. I worked with it for about a year but never got comfy with the skinny neck. In late '07 I took the 660/12 plunge (BBR - I've seen some nice flames on 660/12 BBRs here, but I wouldn't trade mine for any of 'em). I then traded the 360/12 for a 360/6 in amberglo and put the scatterwounds on that.
For quite a while, I thought that my luthier (a great guy whom I have no other reasons to mistrust at all) had tampered with the scatterwounds. I like to play heavily overdriven as much as I do clean, and I found little difference in terms of playing overdriven chords on the neck pups between the 360 with the toasters and my Heritage 555 (their superior "knockoff" of an ES-335) with SD-'59s, and, quite honestly, the series of Les Pauls I used to own. As a reference point, I would cite the nasty post-Chuck Berry chordal sound Keith Richards used on "Miss Amanda Jones." Puketrescent mud city! And very surprising with the Ric. I actually have no problem with this for lead lines - it's a great sound, and certainly distinctive with the Ric as opposed to the humbucker guitars - but no versatility, as striking a second string on any of those instruments at those settings is tonal catastrophe. Anyway, I tried the same amp setting and plugged in the 660/12. Same stuff. It's not the toasters, it's the neck pup as a phenom in general. I expected more tonal clarity out of single coils - I haven't had such negative experiences with Fender guitars.
So, my basic question is - how would it affect the tonality of the bass switch settings if I replaced my 360 with a 340 or 370 with scatters? Would it tend to clean up the muddiness to have the middle and neck mixed? I have owned and played several guitars, but never a bass/treble pup setup with three pups (as opposed to the 5-way switching of a Strat). I want to act on this fairly quickly (if I'm going to) due to the dinosauring of the 3-pup option.
Three years back I purchased a 360/12 and put a 12-string saddle (duh) and scatterwounds on it. I worked with it for about a year but never got comfy with the skinny neck. In late '07 I took the 660/12 plunge (BBR - I've seen some nice flames on 660/12 BBRs here, but I wouldn't trade mine for any of 'em). I then traded the 360/12 for a 360/6 in amberglo and put the scatterwounds on that.
For quite a while, I thought that my luthier (a great guy whom I have no other reasons to mistrust at all) had tampered with the scatterwounds. I like to play heavily overdriven as much as I do clean, and I found little difference in terms of playing overdriven chords on the neck pups between the 360 with the toasters and my Heritage 555 (their superior "knockoff" of an ES-335) with SD-'59s, and, quite honestly, the series of Les Pauls I used to own. As a reference point, I would cite the nasty post-Chuck Berry chordal sound Keith Richards used on "Miss Amanda Jones." Puketrescent mud city! And very surprising with the Ric. I actually have no problem with this for lead lines - it's a great sound, and certainly distinctive with the Ric as opposed to the humbucker guitars - but no versatility, as striking a second string on any of those instruments at those settings is tonal catastrophe. Anyway, I tried the same amp setting and plugged in the 660/12. Same stuff. It's not the toasters, it's the neck pup as a phenom in general. I expected more tonal clarity out of single coils - I haven't had such negative experiences with Fender guitars.
So, my basic question is - how would it affect the tonality of the bass switch settings if I replaced my 360 with a 340 or 370 with scatters? Would it tend to clean up the muddiness to have the middle and neck mixed? I have owned and played several guitars, but never a bass/treble pup setup with three pups (as opposed to the 5-way switching of a Strat). I want to act on this fairly quickly (if I'm going to) due to the dinosauring of the 3-pup option.