12 string intonation help, please...
Posted: Thu Nov 18, 2021 2:33 pm
Hello,
I've personally been setting up my 4 RIC's ( 2x12 strings, 6 string & bass ) for years now with good success and without any particular issues, but I've now run into an issue with one of my 12 strings that I want to be cautious about how to fix. Hoping there's someone here that can properly advise.
I'm using Pyramid Chrome Flats - 010-046.5 with a 6 saddle 12 string bridge as I have been using for years. Recently changed the strings after an extended period of non-use, checked all of my setup measurements and intonation. All seems well. But after a short period of playing, I've noticed that the octave 'A' string has a pronounced 'sitar' buzz. This occurs only when fretting the A string course starting at the 2nd fret and going up the neck gradually disappearing by the 7th fret AND it's ONLY the octave A string buzzing - no other 'sitar' buzzing on any other courses or even the entire low A string.
The guitar is setup atm with a nearly flat neck - only a very slight relief. Action otherwise is pretty low. I used a fret level checker thinking maybe I had a high or low fret some where in the area, but found nothing. After more analyzing, the buzzing seems to be localized at the bridge rather than buzzing against the fretboard. The frets overall on this guitar are in excellent condition. In this case, I would normally think that a little massaging of the octave bridge slot would remedy. With this in mind, I did very carefully attempt to cleanup and profile the octave A string bridge saddle with a nut file, but that didn't seem to reduce the buzz much if at all. Of course, this may require more aggressive profiling if indeed the 'fix', but it's here where I want to make sure I'm working at this properly.
I suppose it's also possible I have a bad A octave string, but unfortunately as far as I'm aware, one cannot buy Pyramid flat wound singles. I guess I could try another string mfg'r flat wound assuming there are alternative options out there, but spending $40 or so on another set of Pyramid strings just to 'test' a string seems punitive.
One last thing that seem strange... When the A string course is perfectly in tune with each other - open fret, fretting the A string course gets more and more out of tune ( to each other ) as I fret up the guitar. At the 12th fret the A octave string is 22 cents out of tune sharp. So, open fret, both A strings are perfect 0.00 440A. At the 12th fret, the low octave is 0.0, but the octave A is +22 cents. Yes, I undertand that using a 6 saddle bridge will not allow perfect intonation. Teh other 5 courses do not exhibit this issue. They are reasonably close to being 'perfect' intonated.
Open to suggestions! Thanks in advance!
~ Greg
I've personally been setting up my 4 RIC's ( 2x12 strings, 6 string & bass ) for years now with good success and without any particular issues, but I've now run into an issue with one of my 12 strings that I want to be cautious about how to fix. Hoping there's someone here that can properly advise.
I'm using Pyramid Chrome Flats - 010-046.5 with a 6 saddle 12 string bridge as I have been using for years. Recently changed the strings after an extended period of non-use, checked all of my setup measurements and intonation. All seems well. But after a short period of playing, I've noticed that the octave 'A' string has a pronounced 'sitar' buzz. This occurs only when fretting the A string course starting at the 2nd fret and going up the neck gradually disappearing by the 7th fret AND it's ONLY the octave A string buzzing - no other 'sitar' buzzing on any other courses or even the entire low A string.
The guitar is setup atm with a nearly flat neck - only a very slight relief. Action otherwise is pretty low. I used a fret level checker thinking maybe I had a high or low fret some where in the area, but found nothing. After more analyzing, the buzzing seems to be localized at the bridge rather than buzzing against the fretboard. The frets overall on this guitar are in excellent condition. In this case, I would normally think that a little massaging of the octave bridge slot would remedy. With this in mind, I did very carefully attempt to cleanup and profile the octave A string bridge saddle with a nut file, but that didn't seem to reduce the buzz much if at all. Of course, this may require more aggressive profiling if indeed the 'fix', but it's here where I want to make sure I'm working at this properly.
I suppose it's also possible I have a bad A octave string, but unfortunately as far as I'm aware, one cannot buy Pyramid flat wound singles. I guess I could try another string mfg'r flat wound assuming there are alternative options out there, but spending $40 or so on another set of Pyramid strings just to 'test' a string seems punitive.
One last thing that seem strange... When the A string course is perfectly in tune with each other - open fret, fretting the A string course gets more and more out of tune ( to each other ) as I fret up the guitar. At the 12th fret the A octave string is 22 cents out of tune sharp. So, open fret, both A strings are perfect 0.00 440A. At the 12th fret, the low octave is 0.0, but the octave A is +22 cents. Yes, I undertand that using a 6 saddle bridge will not allow perfect intonation. Teh other 5 courses do not exhibit this issue. They are reasonably close to being 'perfect' intonated.
Open to suggestions! Thanks in advance!
~ Greg