I'm in top 5 mood... :Paul McCartney

[RutleDirk]

Oh, I couldn't...OK, let's just go with:

Every Night
Band On The Run
Listen to What the Man Said
Mull Of Kintyre
Too Many People

Honorable mention:

Junior's Farm
Let Me Roll It
Maybe I'm Amazed
Shake a Hand (I know, he didn't write it, but wow!)
Soily

[revolver323]

In no particular order:

See Your Sunshine
Another Day
Back Seat of My Car
Arrow Through Me
My Brave Face

[lyle_from_minneapolis]

No order, and subject to change on a daily basis...but for the moment:

Don't Let It Bring You down
Venus and Mars (yeah, just the intro to Rock Show...can't get enough of it!)
Heart of the Country
Too Many People
Bluebird

[congerz83]

These discussions should be mandatory. LOL!!!

[congerz83]

As long as someone brought up "Rock Show" i absolutely LOVE the outro bit on the album version.

[bottom4]

Here's mine for now... 5 is impossible IMO

A different listing:

Calico Skies
C’mon People
Dear Friend
End of the End
Monkberry Moon Delight

[harley]

I'm not sure I could ever give a "once and for all" top five but without too much reviewing of playlists or albums....

Let Me Roll It
Goodnight Tonight
Jet
Vintage Clothes (much better than I expected)
Helen Wheels

Harley

[rickinroma]

Love In Song
The Pound Is Sinking
Dress Me Up As A Robber
Winter Rose
English Tea

[craig55]

This is a tough one. Four factors come into play.
1. Where and what was I doing when the song came out and I started listening to it?
2. Is it a song I like to sing or Play on Bass or Guitar?
3. Is it a song with meaning to me?
Is it a song I would like to track in my studio?

Maybe I'm Amazed
Take it Away
Get out of My Way
Band on the Run
Time to Hide
bonus:
She's my Baby
Not such a Bad Boy

[JakeK]

yes, they are all the hits, but I'm not an "in-depth" fan. I do like the album with "Junk" on it very much, though.

That would be the 40-year-old album, McCartney.

1. Maybe I'm Amazed
2. Band on the Run
3. Live and Let Die
4. Uncle Albert/Admiral Halsey
5. Let Me Roll It

[harley]

After listing Vintage Clothes in my post I went back and listened to that whole medley from Memory Almost Full. I think it's very under-rated, as is the whole album.

I also need to find a way to fit 15 or 20 songs into my top five.

[johnnysain]

1. Coming Up
2. Silly Love Songs
3. Bluebird
4. Ebony and Ivory
5. Simply Having a Wonderful Christmas Time

[nattiep]

I don't really have an order. Just picking 5 songs was too hard.

Girlfriend
Figure Of Eight
Letting Go
I'm Carrying
The Back Seat Of My Car