RicUpNorth wrote:scott_s wrote:...I spent a lot of time trying to get his sound with other guitars and the wrong types of amps, I'm finally getting closer these days.
Have to ask, what amps are getting you close? I know he left bed AC30s...
Sure, I'll tell the story chronologically if you don't mind.
From the beginning, I've played on amps that my dad and/or I built. The first tube amp made probably 10W and didn't have a tone control. I read a bunch of hype online about tweed amps and built myself a 5E7 Bandmaster and 5F2A Princeton clone from Weber kits. After that, I went really primitive and built a 5B5 Pro completely from scratch, forming my own chassis from bent aluminum sheet and cutting a speaker baffle from 3/8" plywood to use in the Bandmaster cabinet. All great-sounding amps, with warm cleans that transition smoothly into a great grinding overdrive when you crank them. But that midrange warmth also obscures the fast arpeggios, and I kept cranking up the treble to try to get more definition out of the low strings, to no one's pleasure.
Recently, it dawned on me that most of the amps Buck is known for using (BF/SF Fender Twins, Mesa/Boogies, Vox AC30s) have a tone stack that scoops out some amount of midrange. I used the Duncan Tone Stack Calculator to model a Blackface tone circuit with the midrange control all the way up for minimal scoop but the bass and treble controls set fairly neutral:
I set my Boss EQ pedal for that shape and put it in front of my tweed clones -- it was a revelation! There was the clarity and definition (without ear-piercing brightness) I'd been looking for all this time! And it only took me 20 years or so to put it together.
So I wasted very little time in hacking both my 5F2A and 5B5 clones to include a bass/treble tone stack modeled on the BF Champ. The 15k mid resistor allows plenty of scoop without eating too much gain. These mutts have me jazzed to play guitar again, now that the sound I'm hearing is so much closer to the sound I've been wanting to make!
As I understand it, the earliest Peter Buck rig was just his Rickenbacker or Telecaster into a Fender Twin Reverb with nothing but a cord in between. (You can see the Twin behind Peter in
wisdom's picture above.) That would give you the ultimate squeaky-clean scooped Fender sound. Don't forget the 0.013 gauge flatwounds!
