Hum Cancelling - another option?
Moderators: rickenbrother, ajish4
Hum Cancelling - another option?
I have nagged at RIC for years to develop a "toasterbucker" to address the single coil hum that all such equipped guitars and basses, not just RIC instruments, are prone to exhibit, and that approaches "vintage" chime and jangle, instead of the drive that HB-1 pickups are known for.
But, as we all know, no matter what system of added coil hum reduction is tried, it affects tone. This stems from the original idea that it takes two identical coils, one opposite in both magnetic and electrical polarity to the other, to buck hum.
I ran across this reference in another forum. It seems to work well. Maybe not perfectly, but well enough. I wonder if it could be adapted to RIC instruments:
http://www.ilitchelectronics.com/hum-canceling-systems/
Please discuss.
But, as we all know, no matter what system of added coil hum reduction is tried, it affects tone. This stems from the original idea that it takes two identical coils, one opposite in both magnetic and electrical polarity to the other, to buck hum.
I ran across this reference in another forum. It seems to work well. Maybe not perfectly, but well enough. I wonder if it could be adapted to RIC instruments:
http://www.ilitchelectronics.com/hum-canceling-systems/
Please discuss.
- cassius987
- Senior Member
- Posts: 4723
- Joined: Mon Aug 04, 2008 2:11 pm
Re: Hum Cancelling - another option?
Well, RWRP doesn't affect tone other than requiring both volumes be up which itself affects tone independent of the RWRP. Audere tried to get around this with a dummy coil for Jazz Basses so either pickup can be soloed without hum.
Re: Hum Cancelling - another option?
That is what Alembic has been doing for many decades in their Series I and Series II electronics. Very successfully, too.cassius987 wrote:...Audere tried to get around this with a dummy coil for Jazz Basses so either pickup can be soloed without hum.
Re: Hum Cancelling - another option?
That's the entire point of my post. Everything that uses a "conventional" dummy coil affects tone significantely, including the Strat Elite and others like it. I'm wondering what this non-conventional approach to noise reduction would do on a Rick. The Fender folks seem to think it has minimal effect on a Strat pickup tone with significant noise reduction.
-
- New member
- Posts: 84
- Joined: Wed Aug 22, 2007 11:36 am
- Contact:
Re: Hum Cancelling - another option?
That's for a different issue (ground loops and other AC related hum IIRC), not single coil hum.
Re: Hum Cancelling - another option?
I haven't looked into it in detail, but Music Man is now putting an active noise cancelling system in single coil equipped guitars. It's in my Armada MM90 (P-90s) and actually works pretty well. You can "A/B" it by flipping the 9V battery door open. Significant hum reduction with very little adverse impact.
Life is suffering; the cause of suffering is desire. Envy is a deadly sin. Save your soul, go ahead and buy another one....
-
- New member
- Posts: 29
- Joined: Sat Jul 11, 2015 2:23 pm
Re: Hum Cancelling - another option?
http://www.creamery-pickups.co.uk/custo ... cancelling
Toasterbuckers have landed. After numerous emails back and forth with Jaime, I got a set of these wound with 43awg to 9k at the neck and 10.5k bridge. Slightly fatter sounding than a single coil but still very "Rick".
I know that there is some debate which Toaster is better, the 12ks or the 7.4ks, so I decided to split the difference when it came to the output of these.
Toasterbuckers have landed. After numerous emails back and forth with Jaime, I got a set of these wound with 43awg to 9k at the neck and 10.5k bridge. Slightly fatter sounding than a single coil but still very "Rick".
I know that there is some debate which Toaster is better, the 12ks or the 7.4ks, so I decided to split the difference when it came to the output of these.
- sloop_john_b
- Rick-a-holic
- Posts: 13843
- Joined: Tue Jan 25, 2005 6:00 am
Re: Hum Cancelling - another option?
Has anyone tried these yet? I'm super interested in the High '68 Humbucker.Dr. Frankenrick wrote:http://www.creamery-pickups.co.uk/custo ... cancelling
Toasterbuckers have landed. After numerous emails back and forth with Jaime, I got a set of these wound with 43awg to 9k at the neck and 10.5k bridge. Slightly fatter sounding than a single coil but still very "Rick".
I know that there is some debate which Toaster is better, the 12ks or the 7.4ks, so I decided to split the difference when it came to the output of these.